Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Here’s how to respectfully respond to public scrutiny

In today's hyper-connected world, it's easy for criticisms and negative comments to spread like wildfire, potentially damaging your reputation and credibility.

company business leader addresses a tough crowd

Photo credits:
kasto / Adobe Stock

Profile photo of Fast Company Executive Board

Being a company leader who is also a public speaker or author of books and articles comes with its own set of challenges. One of the biggest challenges is dealing with public scrutiny, especially when someone doesn’t agree with your professional viewpoint or is upset about what you said.

To help leaders face this situation head-on, a group of Fast Company Executive Board members explores some strategies for handling public scrutiny and saving face when dealing with criticism or backlash. Whether you’re a seasoned public speaker or a new author, these tips can help you navigate the rough waters of public scrutiny and emerge stronger and more successful.

1. THINK BEFORE RESPONDING

Whatever you do, never answer back emotionally without carefully thinking about how to respond appropriately. Sometimes the person who disagrees has a valid point. Having empathy, being able to “agree to disagree,” and even using humor are just some ways that you can coolly deflect any disagreements without appearing like a sore loser in the eyes of the public. – Zain Jaffer, Zain Ventures

2. BE RESPECTFUL

Expecting everyone to agree with you is a fool’s errand when you’re publishing or presenting your ideas. A distinctive and unapologetic point of view is what enables you to stand out. Be respectful and make room for those who disagree or offer alternatives to your perspective. – Karen Starns, OJO Canada

3. ACCEPT IT AND MOVE ON

As a leader, it’s important to remember that not everyone will agree with what you have to say, and that’s okay. We must be able to brush it off and move on without being affected by it. That also means you don’t have to change your opinion just because someone disagrees with it. That being said, it is important to be aware of how your words might affect others. – Rudy Mawer, Mawer Capital

4. BE COMPASSIONATE AND UNDERSTANDING

Being a public figure is difficult! Anything and everything you do or say will be judged, misunderstood, and even misinterpreted. When you come across someone who disagrees with your views, remember it’s not your job to convince everyone! When someone doesn’t agree with you, be compassionate and understand them. Reassure them that it’s not personal. – Candice Georgiadis, Digital Agency, Inc

5. THANK THE PERSON FOR SPEAKING UP

As a leader, being educated on the topics you promote is important, and being data-driven with your viewpoints and statements must be a priority. This ensures that what you are saying is defensible. Being open to new data that could alter or refine your perspective is always helpful, therefore if it is presented to you, acknowledging it and thanking the person for sharing it is the best first step. – Chad Engelgau, Acxiom

6. MAKE IT A CONVERSATION

Don’t view anything you do as a presentation. Treat everything as a conversation. Sure, you’re writing or speaking to express your personal opinion. But make sure you’re also expressing an openness to learn. End every article or speech you write with an invitation for viewers to respond. That way, you’ll get new ideas, you’ll get feedback, and you’ll be a whole lot less likely to get attacked. – Barry Fiske, Merkle

7. RESPECTFULLY EXPLAIN WHY YOU DISAGREE

It’s important to realize that it’s impossible to please everyone. Therefore, you can acknowledge that your critic has a right to their opinion, even if it differs from yours. Listen to your critic, acknowledge their point of view, and then respectfully explain why you disagree. By being respectful and understanding, you leave everyone with a positive impression. – Syed Balkhi, WPBeginner

8. REMAIN CALM AND COLLECTED

I strive to remain calm and collected in these situations, as responding emotionally can often worsen the situation. I also take the time to listen to what they have to say, understand their perspective, and then respond respectfully. This helps ensure that I maintain a positive relationship with the person, even if I disagree with the issue at hand. – Kristin Marquet, Marquet Media, LLC

9. DON’T ENGAGE WITH OR BE A TROLL

If you are active online and post a lot of opinions, you will invariably get some detractors. While you should welcome a healthy debate, it’s best to ignore those who attack personally or engage in dishonest debate. You can look out for the logical fallacies called out by HubSpot. – Rio Longacre, Slalom Consulting

10. STAY ALIGNED WITH YOUR VALUES

See someone who doesn’t agree with you as an opportunity to learn from their perspective. It helps to also be aware that what you say can “trigger” others based on their personal viewpoints. Remember it’s not personal, therefore, acknowledge their position, thank them for their viewpoint, and then reiterate your viewpoint. – Cheryl Cran, NextMapping

11. ENGAGE WITH PR

Engaging the public relations team prior to a speaking event is extremely helpful. Typically, a pre-read is shared as well as audience demographics. A PR representative is also helpful to guide and coach on authenticity and transparency balanced with audience-appropriate dialogue. – Britton Bloch, Navy Federal

12. DON’T BE AFRAID TO CHANGE YOUR MIND

Listen and empathize with other points of view. Focus on the values you share first and clarify where you diverge if needed. Don’t be afraid to change your mind if you think you were wrong. This is a sign of high intelligence and self-confidence, not a sign of weakness. – Isabelle Guis, Commvault

13. LISTEN TO THEIR POINT OF VIEW

Rather than take offense or argue with the other side, it’s a great opportunity to put on your best diversity of thinking hat and try to see another point of view. Use it as an opportunity to start a broader conversation and expand your ideas to a larger audience. – Eric Schurke, Moneypenny

14. ADDRESS THE SOURCE OF THE CRITICISM

Any time you share a point of view that is provocative or that challenges conventionality, you’re inviting engagement, and that’s not necessarily a bad thing. When your ideas are challenged, it’s always good to acknowledge the scrutiny if possible. Simply addressing the source of criticism can often refocus the dialogue on the content rather than the contention. – Bryan Goodpaster, Marks, an sgsco company

15. EMBRACE THE OPPOSITION

If you write something that people scrutinize, it usually means you have a strong enough POV. The very best POVs have opposition to them. Expect the opposition and even embrace it, because that means there is an opportunity to strengthen your POV even more. – James Gilbert, Flip