At one time or another, we all have to deal with a down market cycle. My industry—drayage—has been up and down a few times since 2019. The peaks and valleys were heightened by pandemic-driven market influences on shipping and supply chain logistics, but the fact that the market fluctuated was nothing new.
Some companies make the mistakes of contraction and budget cutting to head off missed forecasts and lower revenue expectations. It’s always a good idea to make sure your business is running as efficiently as possible, but a down market isn’t a time to turn tail and run. It’s the perfect opportunity to optimize your organization to be able to pounce when a down market cranks back up. Bet on your future rather than standing pat on what worked in the past.
Here are two ways to gain a competitive advantage in a down market.
1. OPTIMIZE EFFICIENCY AND AUTOMATE PROCESSES
Downmarket cycles are ideal for analyzing how technology can make you a stronger competitor. Whether it’s a new software platform that modernizes your workflow through automation, machine learning, or generative AI, or it’s a mobile application that improves collaboration or digitalizes a traditionally manual process, the investment makes sense because it helps you:
- Cut costs (e.g., automate low-level tasks, increase efficiency and productivity, reduce travel expenses, etc.)
- Identify redundancies and bottlenecks
- Maintain headcount by shifting roles from task-oriented to something more strategic
You don’t necessarily need to be an early adopter or take extra risks on the bleeding edge of untested technology, but postponing technology-based optimization exposes you to competitive risk, both during and after the down market. A recent Accenture study found that 76 percent of freight and logistics companies felt that not focusing on technology optimization would “seriously endanger their business.” Meanwhile, 86 percent of manufacturing executives cite smart factory solutions as the most effective path to competitive advantage. In other words, sidelining technology is a risk while focusing on it is a win—green lights all the way.
Where should you start? There are definitely some industry-specific optimizations you may need to consider. But every industry benefits from adopting state-of-the-art, best-in-class technology to “do more with less.” Achieving new levels of efficiency through system integration and workflow automation frees you up to focus on delighting customers.
2. PROTECT (AND EXPAND?) EXISTING REVENUE STREAM: CUSTOMERS
Marketing is typically one of the first cost centers to be cut back during a down market. Alas, if you cut marketing, then lead generation will suffer. If new revenue is hard to come by, focus your efforts on recurring revenue from existing customers.
Unless you already have one in place, consider starting a customer success function. Perhaps go as far as hiring a director of customer success. I’m consistently amazed at how many drayage carriers do not have a customer success function in their organization. By echoing the success that technology companies have with focusing on customer success, drayage carriers could impact their growth opportunities, workforce challenges, and supply chain logistics hurdles that take such a toll during down market cycles.
The key to improving customer success is to demonstrate the real value that you’re providing. Details matter because customers don’t always track the same key performance indicators (KPIs) as you. And data-driven validation makes it even easier to illustrate your value.
Here are a few ideas on how to make it happen in your organization:
- Conduct monthly/quarterly reviews with customers to show them exactly how their business is better because of your product or service (e.g., we use data that points to metrics such as how much less time drayage carrier dispatchers spent with redundant tasks, how much faster they got paid from customers, etc.).
- Arm customers with tools they can use to improve their customers’ experiences. For example, PortPro digitalizes operations for drayage carriers and provides visibility through a single dashboard. Carriers can then customize that dashboard for their customers to provide visibility into the status of their freight or on KPIs that are important to their business.
- Educate customers on market trends. Develop a content marketing strategy (featuring webinars, playbooks, guides, third-party research and analysis, etc.) that positions you as a trusted industry resource that your customers can rely on. When customers view you as a problem-solving partner instead of a supplier or vendor, you’ll be in the driver’s seat the next time they’re approached by one of your competitors (which will definitely happen).
DON’T WASTE A DOWN MARKET OPPORTUNITY
Recognize that some market influences are simply out of your control. Geo-politics, weather-based events, pandemics, and the regulatory labyrinth of global commerce are bound to tighten your market eventually. When it happens, use the time to prepare for the upswing. Sometimes those windows open and close quickly. Improving agility will give you the best chance of success when the “up” market begins.
Toni Ann Careccio is chief customer officer & board member at PortPro Technologies, Inc. She leads client experience and marketing.