The debate still rages: should workers work at home or in the office? Remote work sustained many businesses during the pandemic, and hybrid models have kept worker energy high. But now, as the U.S. job market weakens, employers are pulling back on remote options and demanding a return to the office.
Meanwhile, workers still want flexibility. A GoodHire survey of 3,500 U.S. employees in 2021 found 61% were willing to take a pay cut to continue working remotely. In August 2022, Gallup found employee desire to work from home had doubled since October of the previous year, and 60% of remote-capable workers wanted a long-term hybrid work arrangement. Additionally, employees who worked anywhere other than their preferred location experienced lower engagement, higher burnout, and a greater desire to quit.
In this “stay at home” versus “come back” battle, leaders and employees alike are overlooking how much our intentions have in common: we all want to work where work works best. If leaders want employees to believe their best work happens in person, they need to incentivize the office to be that place.
WE NEED PERSONAL CONNECTIONS MORE THAN EVER
Developing and nurturing relationships in work and personal life has always been important, but now, in this disconnected world, both are harder to maintain than ever. A 2010 study found togetherness and social connections have as big an impact on our health as not smoking and a greater impact than exercise. But the pandemic increased rates of isolation and loneliness, which has been associated with a 30% increased risk of heart attack and stroke.
Feeling disconnected can be a painful personal struggle, but employees working from home also feel more disconnected from their colleagues and company than those working in person. Feeling disconnected from a job causes people to miss out on opportunities to contribute and collaborate and form more intimate connections with coworkers and the company. Leaders want people in the office because it’s easier to build a positive culture of belonging and curiosity, instill a sense of purpose and connection to company goals, and facilitate collaboration, creativity, and innovation—all key elements for a company and its people to grow.
ANSWER THEIR “WIIFM”
At Clearfield, to get our team members to value spending their time at the office in a hybrid world, we always talk about answering their WIIFM or “What’s in it for me?” If leaders want people back to do their best work in the office and benefit from these in-person workplace connections, they need to make that answer clear. To do that, we need to create in-person experiences that our team members want—opportunities for building connections and individual development.
Employees want to use in-person time to rebuild bonds with their team members, collaborate, and socialize. Fun and food draw the biggest crowds, and social activities can be a good start to nurturing coworker relationships. Shift the focus of those relationships away from parties by investing in the physical environment to facilitate more productive ways for people to spend in-person time together. Cubicle farms do little to promote collaboration, so instead, prioritize comfortable spaces with communal areas designed for sharing ideas.
Since our switch to hybrid, we have been working to build our “mothership” at Clearfield into the space our employees want to use to do their best work—open areas with bright lighting and fewer cubes, more conference rooms, and training spaces. By offering them in-person training and learning opportunities, they come to do their jobs better, develop new skills, and pave their own path of career growth. We get them back by making the office a place that gives back to them.
Our leadership teams also use that in-person time wisely. Of course, we need to walk the talk, show up to the office, and demonstrate we can use it to do our best work. While there, we should also make an effort to interact one-on-one with the team members who decide to join us and hold meaningful conversations with each employee in the office.
We’re all still learning how to navigate the best path forward, but by asking our employees questions about how to make their in-person time even better and what we can do to help, leaders can keep the office a place where working works best for more people.
REMOTE, HYBRID, AND ONE-ON-ONES ARE TOOLS
There are benefits to all possible options—remote, hybrid, and in person—depending on the situation. Remote work helps open the talent pool to fill specialized roles and reduces business costs, increasing opportunities for more people to enter into entrepreneurship and the global workforce. A 2022 study found the increased satisfaction employees experienced through hybrid work reduced attrition by 33%. In a 2020 PwC survey of office workers, nearly nine out of 10 agreed that the office was critical for collaboration and building relationships.
In today’s workplace, remote options, like hybrid and one-on-ones, are tools to use when they serve the company’s best interests. When Clearfield was smaller, we ran things differently than we do today, now that we’re valued at over a billion dollars. We went from having no remote team members to hiring fully remote teams. This will need to change again when we grow even larger in order to facilitate more effective business and drive individual development. Staying anchored in our values, we can take feedback, figure out what’s working, and make tactical changes with what’s not as we grow.
Instead of looking at remote or hybrid as an inevitable future, leaders should see these as another two tools in their kit. Along with in-office experiences, they can balance these three approaches to help their workers do their best work for the company’s best interests. Moving forward and settling into this new next phase of life will be a learning experience for all of us. Even at Clearfield, we’re still making mistakes. It will be clunky, but as we fail, learn, and improve, we can use all three tools to create a better work experience for all.
Cheri Beranek is the President and CEO of Clearfield, providing optical-fiber management and connectivity solutions across North America.