Your online reputation was always directly tied to customer satisfaction. However, in a post-AI world, this is no longer just necessary for customer satisfaction and retention. It is also necessary for SEO and AI visibility through AEO and GEO.
Google’s Helpful Content framework and its E-E-A-T criteria (experience, expertise, authoritativeness, trustworthiness) aren’t pie-in-the-sky concepts. They are the signaling layers below the rankings surface, where your content could cause financial, physical, or even legal harm to someone by providing poor or inaccurate content.
Customer reviews are one of the strongest ways for Google to signal trustworthiness. Google considers the volume, recency, sentiment, and response behavior. An entity that gets 400 Google reviews with 4.6 average star ratings and responds actively to reviews is viewed more favorably than 50 pages of content on its own merit.
This is not a theory.
Review signaling shows up in ranking factor studies across search ranking, appearing in the top factors in Google results. Those operating a your money your life (YMYL) business—one focusing on finances, health, well-being, or personal safety—in a competitive market already know this.
AEO DRAWS ON THE SAME REPUTATION LAYER
As SEO evolves due to AI, answer engine optimization (AEO) focuses on how AI systems use your content to answer queries when posed a question. However, just posting content is not good enough. AI engine design, such as Google’s AI Overviews, only promotes sources showcasing credibility. Having a poor review profile signals low credibility.
When deciding whether to promote your business or your content, marketers need to consider reputation, reliability, and credibility. Questions include how many sources talk about your brand, what they said, whether reviews are fresh and have been responded to, and whether the company has any third-party references. These are some factors determining whether it is worth showcasing.
GEO CLOSES THE LOOP
GEO takes this concept further.
When ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Gemini are asked a question like, “What is the best urgent care clinic near me?” AI will not look at your website first. Instead, it will analyze what it has learned from its knowledge of you elsewhere: reviews, mentions, forums, directory listings, and press.
Your brand reputation, separate from your website, is crucial. A lack of visibility means you are not seen by generative AI, while negative information will cause active filtering. The companies being recommended via AI-generated results have established a solid reputation signal across platforms.
We’re seeing this in the automotive industry. According to Ekho research, 30% of consumers are already researching their next vehicle purchase using generative AI, with ChatGPT accounting for 68% of those searches. This number is only growing in YMYL verticals, as we see from our internal data working with clients in that sector.
A PLAYBOOK FOR ALL INDUSTRIES
A good place to begin understanding reputation’s impact on businesses is the used car industry. It represents a scenario with a high trust deficit and high stakes. Customers spend tens of thousands of dollars on car deals with strangers.
I wrote a marketing playbook for Get My Auto to address the trust deficit. While aimed at independent and used car dealers, the recommendations can be applied to other industries, too. There are three key aspects in my recommended approach to reputation management.
First, I recommend using systematic review acquisitions, making sure that a reputation signal appears on every website page, with proactive reputation management. This means monitoring reviews and online sentiment around your brand and actively and strategically responding to negative reviews. I recommend capturing one Google review per sale, as part of the purchase delivery process. Send an automatic text message with a review request link within 30 minutes of finalizing the deal. Capitalize on the client’s satisfaction.
Second, your company should respond to both positive and negative reviews within 24 hours. Responding to positive reviews indicates customer appreciation, which can go a long way. Responding to negatives or less than perfect reviews means that you care for all your customers, even unhappy ones, and you are attempting to resolve the situation. And even if this situation remains unresolved, future customers (and search engines) know that tried, and that helps with credibility and trust.
Third, ensure reviews are secured on third-party verified feeds, such as Google, DealerRater, Yelp, BBB, Cars.com, or Facebook. Testimonials appearing on the website are good, but can be faked. Hence, it is important to have a third-party review system validating reviews and testimonials.
CREATE A SYSTEM FOR YOUR REPUTATION
Companies react to reputation issues by managing their image after an unfavorable review. I recommend a different approach, as consistency is everything.
Your proactive reputation management system should include:
- An organized review request process correlated with milestones
- Protocols for responding to favorable and unfavorable reviews with assigned individuals and timeframes
- Coverage not only on Google, but all AI-indexed platforms
- Third-party review streams shown on your website in real time
- Auditing your mentions, your directory presence, and your name/address/phone (NAP) data across the web
The latter is important beyond local SEO. Inconsistent NAP data across multiple directories hurts your local SEO rankings, but also causes entity disambiguation. This makes it difficult for AI engines to identify your brand and know you’re the company being reviewed.
THE COMPOUNDING EFFECT
Ten reviews per month for a year is superior to twice that amount in a shorter timeframe because of recency, volume, and engagement signals—factors that AI takes into account.
Business reputation matters. Negative reputations such as negative reviews or sentiment can be a barrier to growth. Search engines know and consider that in their algorithms, in particular in sensitive industries such as financial or healthcare. Having a plan to address those, and encourage positive reviews, helps with customer retention and trust and also improves SEO.
Al Sefati is CEO of Clarity Digital.