Of the many departments that make up modern enterprises, there are perhaps few whose work is as often misunderstood as the design team. Common understanding ranges from “making things look pretty” to “improving user experience”—but many non-design or design-adjacent folks remain foggy on the details. Why is this? Why is design, as a practice, so prone to confusion and ambiguity?
Andy Vitale, executive vice president of design at Rocket Companies, thinks the practice’s ambiguous nature stems less from the nature of design itself and more from the inherently complex and varied problems with which designers concern themselves. “I don’t know that design itself is more prone to ambiguity than other areas, but when we create products or devise solutions for people, it is often without a clear articulation of the initial problem. Someone will often raise a rather vague problem statement and ask, ‘What should we do?’,” Vitale explains. “The problems themselves are often ambiguous.”
Designers often operate in a space of uncertainty: they are unclear about what the right problem to solve is and yet they have to move quickly to devise a solution. “Design is really a powerful tool when it comes to dealing with uncertainty, for a few reasons,” he explains. “First, we have the ability to experiment, test, learn, and iterate quickly. We spend of time getting a nuanced understanding of the problem, and the desired outcome. Second, we develop empathy as we spend time with people, understanding their needs, goals and opportunities in a greater context.
Through this process of experimentation and inquiry, designers surface a nuanced understanding of what is lacking simply not serving in a product. “We are able to get clarity, constantly refining the ‘why.’ Our iterative process helps us understand if we’re on the right track. Designers also work to frame and reframe that problem to bring alignment with other teams. This is how design thinking works—it tees us up as stewards to bring clarity into ambiguous spaces.”
Vitale asserts that this current generation of designers is better equipped than their predecessors to deal with the inherent ambiguity in the design process. Part of this capability, he says, stems from the advent of new technologies that have essentially evolved alongside current designers. “In the early days of design, you would spend a lot of time creating a solution that you believe is right: sometimes that was a physical product, later a digital product. And people would use it, and they’d either adopt it because it would be great, or they’d ignore it if it didn’t solve their problems,” he says.
The speed of technology, Vitale says, has given designers an iterative power that their predecessors lacked. “We’re able to prototype, to put live code out there, release a beta version of a product, and get real-time feedback—and iterate on the fly based on that feedback,” he says. “And that’s being taught to designers today. So they’re able to both understand how to facilitate a conversation that takes into account the different perspectives in the room, incorporate those voices with the real-time feedback, and then leverage tools to continually develop, evolve, and improve products and solutions.”
Vitale says that one of designers’ superpowers is “the ability to cast a vision, to inspire people to feel, to believe in something.” This is best accomplished by starting with an idea in lower fidelity, or is in some way imperfect, to spark conversations and align people around a common goal. “Designers inspire thinking around what could be—the art of the possible,” he says. “They enable everyone involved to feel shared ownership of an experience, product or service,. It also gets them thinking, ‘Wow, this would be game-changing if we could do this.’” Designers leverage storytelling, prototyping, and an aspirational vision to inspire what companies build.
Vitale asserts that a company’s design team is only as mature as the company’s ability to understand and leverage design. “Design leaders have to really spend their time understanding business goals and needs,” he says. In turn, company leaders need to invest in their relationships with their design teams and involve them every step of the way. When these relationships grow successfully, “designers have executives and business understanding the impact and capabilities of their design organization,” Vitale says. “There’s an alignment that the rest of the company sees and has bought into.”
That alignment of vision throughout the company is what ultimately yields transformational products and services that address customer pain points, delight users, and truly meet clients’ needs. “Design is truly a differentiator,” he says. “That the ability to connect directly to customers translates to business value.”