Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The right to data dignity—in this universe or the metaverse

The metaverse is an uncharted world. There are new demands—and new uncertainties. The rights of your customers, however, are clear and non-negotiable.

Robot holding a key to a lock

[Images: phonlamaiphoto/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Tom Chavez

A new media technology arrives. It grows quickly in popularity and profit. Questions of privacy arise. Pro-regulation movements, and those staunchly against it, form.

No, it’s not the recently launched Meta Quest Pro or another newfangled invention of the metaverse—though that assumption is justified given the Texas Attorney General’s lawsuits over Google and Meta’s collection of biometric data. 

Instead, it’s the 1888 leather-and-wood Kodak portable camera; a game-changer hailed for rapidly taking 100 photos. For the same reason, it faced high-profile public scrutiny.

Kodak’s invention beckoned society to look at the right of people “to be let alone,” Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis—a future Supreme Court justice—penned in an 1890 essay in the Harvard Law Review. The cameras, they said, threatened to make it so that “what is whispered in the closet shall be proclaimed from the house-tops.”

If they only knew how far debates have come: The gear has changed, but the fundamental questions remain the same. For example, how much privacy are we entitled to when using new technologies? Where must innovators meet the public to create innovative products yet protect against misuse of personal data?

Compared to the privacy threats of the metaverse, the Kodak camera is prehistoric and perhaps innocent. But something like the Meta Quest Pro—which builds on the Quest 2’s four built-in infrared cameras by adding cameras to the handheld controllers—has more privacy-violating potential than many realize. 

As wearables like metaverse headsets become more common, privacy dangers are terrifying if the technology falls into the wrong hands. The latest headsets can gather data on eye movements, pupil dilations, body temperature, and micro facial expressions that can be easily harvested from the “privacy” of your home and potentially used without your informed consent. 

Meta has already “patented technology to build eye tracking and facial expression tracking into the optical equipment worn to access the metaverse.” Apple, set to launch their competing metaverse headset in 2023, reportedly has patented iris scanning technology for users to make payments biometrically. Can we trust tech giants with our biometric signatures?

UNDERSTANDING THE DATA BEING GIVEN AWAY

We’re starting to give away new kinds of data without understanding its power and peril. 

Perhaps your biometric data indicates above-average anxiety. Should Meta be able to sell that information to a pharmaceutical company that can peddle anxiety meds? Maybe the data says you have an abnormal heart rate. Should your insurance company be able to buy that information from Google and cancel your coverage? What if Matterport sells information on your gait to ICE, who uses that information to identify, arrest, and detain you? The latter scenario isn’t far-fetched. Data-driven deportation is an industry that’s already playing out the worst of dystopian nightmares.

I believe the only way to trust companies with our data is with safeguards. But the laws are years behind. Under pressure, some companies have taken it upon themselves to do better on privacy. For example, Microsoft recently rewrote its artificial intelligence policy under its new “Responsible AI Standard.”

In one significant move, the corporation’s Azure Face service, which Uber uses for identity verification, is no longer as widely available. Companies that want it must apply to prove they are up to par with Microsoft’s ethics standards. That includes those that already have it built into their products. Microsoft is also going a step further by cutting off access to one of the most controversial features, a facial analysis program that identifies whether you are happy, angry, or sad, as well as your age and gender.

Policies that balance the need for progress with consumer guardrails should be the rule, not the exception. Unfortunately, it seems too many companies see only dollar signs.

PERMISSION IS THE KEY

How do companies creating cutting-edge metaverse experiences build users’ trust that their privacy is protected? I believe the answer is simple: permission. 

There’s nothing wrong with tracking a person’s pupils—if it’s with permission. But part of giving permission is understanding the purpose, which should be to enhance the metaverse experience and nothing else unless stated outright.

Permission is also about controlling purpose—applying and changing permissions. For example, metaverse users should be able to control where data goes and if it is shared and sold.

And it is also important to think through worst-case possibilities. How is data stored and protected? If there were a leak, how could biometric data be used against you? There needs to be recourse, remediation, and accountability. In my experience, if companies do this right, customers will come back.

BUILDING PRIVACY BY DESIGN

Privacy shouldn’t be an afterthought for leaders that’s forced by compliance teams. It also shouldn’t be a purely academic ethical exercise.

Being smart about privacy from the inception of an idea can make the metaverse—a broad term that can be confusing and scary to the public because of understandable privacy fears—stronger.

Here are three ways to start:

1. Talk with your customers, not to them. Placing permission at the core can reposition your product from a top-down offering to a partnership with users.

2. Loop in engineers. Just like conversations with customers should be two-way, the ones with those who lay the bricks of the products should be too. Engineers should understand new ways of thinking about users and data.

3. Sometimes, minimizing data collection is the best strategy. There are much bigger risks to misusing biometric data than there are financial rewards. Make sure everyone involved understands this. 

A SUCCESSFUL METAVERSE IS AN ETHICAL ONE

The metaverse is an uncharted world. There are new demands—and new uncertainties. The rights of your customers, however, are clear and non-negotiable.

Leaders, keep this in mind. Follow the law while innovating and pushing boundaries. Do and create what’s unthinkable, but keep users and workers in the loop. Keep safety and responsibility at the forefront. I believe that’s how we can all meet the challenges of this new world—the metaverse—that we may soon inhabit.


Tom Chavez is Chair of The Ethical Project and CEO of privacy and data governance company Ketch.