Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why staying independent matters amidst consolidation

How to resist the urge.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Bill Shirey

Chief Operations Officer · BioCare

Healthcare providers of all types face the temptation to consolidate. The pitch goes something like this: Contract with or sell to a corporate enterprise and stop swimming against a current that favors large conglomerates. Turn over the administrative hassles to someone else, promising convenience and efficiency so you can concentrate on caring for the patient. Relinquish control and decision-making and achieve that elusive work-life balance. Envision your carefree existence.

Few providers resist this temptation. The trend of practices selling to healthcare systems and large medical groups seems inevitable. As of January 2026, 64% of physician practices are owned by—and 82% of physicians are employed by—hospitals, insurers, or other corporate entities.

Healthcare isn’t the only industry experiencing consolidation. It’s happening in fields like veterinary medicine, auto body repair, and legal services. Across industries, business owners are confronting similar questions: Does aligning with scale create value? When does it begin to erode the qualities that made an independent business—free from restrictive contractual covenants or corporate mandates—successful in the first place?

I’m not a healthcare provider, and I can’t fault any business owner for making a decision they feel is best for them. But I have spent most of my career in healthcare and life sciences, working for companies large, small, and in between. I’ve watched the trend toward corporate ownership with growing concern.

Scale offers real advantages such as capital, infrastructure, and administrative support. But those benefits come with trade-offs and limitations. Before signing on the dotted line, owners should understand what they are surrendering in exchange for that too-good-to-be-true deal.

THE TRADE-OFFS OF SCALE

The reasons independent healthcare practices sell or lock themselves into long-term commitments are understandable. Running an independent operation means managing the financial pressures and administrative burdens of ownership while also caring for patients. Joining or ceding certain purchasing decisions to a larger organization can be enticing with the promise of easing the burden of administrative and operational responsibilities.

Yet the financial outcome of a sale of a provider group doesn’t always match financial expectations. A 2021 study found that hospital or health-system ownership was associated with a reduced physician annual income by $2,987. Among nonsurgical specialists, vertical integration was associated with a $9,652 reduction in annual income.

Physicians who no longer must troubleshoot an electronic health records system or manage payroll may instead find themselves navigating the policies and processes of a larger organization. Half of physicians report lower satisfaction after mergers and acquisitions.

The larger issue behind these trade-offs is autonomy. Decisions about staffing, technology, scheduling, operations, and patient care that could be made locally may now require approval from elsewhere, which can become a source of dissatisfaction.

That lesson applies far beyond medicine. Business owners considering being acquired focus on what they will gain. They should consider what they will lose.

THE HIDDEN COST OF CONSOLIDATION

One of the least discussed costs of consolidation is losing choice. Scale can create efficiencies. But leaders should ask where those efficiencies come from. Larger organizations often standardize systems, processes, and vendor relationships because it’s more efficient at scale. The trade-off can be less flexibility to decide how to solve a problem, which partners to work with, or how quickly to respond when circumstances change.

Independence preserves that optionality. An organization not encumbered by enterprise-level oversight or strict contractual limitations can often respond quickly, customize its approach, and get to a decision without navigating multiple organizational layers. In healthcare, where a patient may literally be sitting in a chair waiting for treatment, responsiveness matters. In other industries, the stakes are different, but the competitive advantage of speed is much the same.

Optionality also preserves bargaining power. When a market consolidates around a handful of dominant organizations, customers have fewer places to go. Fewer alternatives can mean less negotiating leverage and less pressure on partners to adapt to individual customer needs. That is why leaders should be careful not to equate efficiency with value.

INDEPENDENCE DOES NOT MEAN GOING IT ALONE

The case for maintaining independence is not an argument for doing everything yourself. In fact, remaining independent requires the opposite. Smaller and mid-sized organizations need partner ecosystems that provide purchasing power, operational expertise, technology know-how, and market knowledge they cannot efficiently develop internally. The key is knowing the difference between access to resources and surrendering control.

When evaluating a strategic partner, ask these questions:

  • Does this organization adapt to the way we operate, or will we have to adapt to it?
  • Does it provide expertise we do not have internally?
  • Will we have meaningful input into the relationship?
  • Are its long-term interests aligned with ours?

That last question becomes important as industries consolidate vertically. A supplier or service provider may also own businesses that compete with its customers. That does not make it the wrong partner, but it is a factor to consider. If resources become constrained, be comfortable with this simple question: Whose interests come first?

The best partners do more than sell a product or service. They become resources, helping customers understand best practices, navigate market changes, and connect with expertise they might not otherwise have.

PRESERVE WHAT MAKES INDEPENDENCE VALUABLE

Maintaining independence and flexibility is not easy. The economic forces driving consolidation are real. Organizations that want to maintain autonomy and choice must continually improve efficiency and find partners that strengthen their capabilities.

But independence itself can be a competitive advantage if leaders know what they are trying to preserve. Before giving it up, consider more than the purchase price or promise of administrative relief. Consider how the decision will affect your ability to utilize your own judgment to respond to customers, select partners, and change direction when the market changes.

The ability to move quickly, make your own decisions, and control your fate may be harder to quantify than the allure of savings and efficiencies through consolidation or long-term contracting. But once surrendered, those advantages can be very difficult to get back.

William Shirey, MBA, is chief operating officer of BioCare.