It was week one of freshman year, and the Econ 101 professor drew a swooping curve on the board. The law of diminishing marginal utility is a classic: The first glass of water quenches best, the first slice of pizza satisfies most, and each one after that delivers a little less.
Going from nothing to something is everything. Then it’s downhill from there.
As a young student, this made intuitive sense to me. It guided my decision-making for years—until I entered advertising and realized that brand recognition often works in the opposite direction.
An ad’s first exposure may deliver almost nothing. By the third or fourth exposure, consumer recall begins to build, then familiarity and, if the campaign works, feeling. The impression’s value can climb with repetition.
Diminishing marginal utility makes sense for tangible things already loaded with value, such as pizza when you’re hungry. But brands are intangible, so trust, relationship, and meaning accumulate over time.
The pattern repeats
Once you notice it, you see accumulation across life, love, and industry. For example, acquired tastes work this way. Few people begin by loving black coffee or olives. Pleasure builds, exposure by exposure, until one day you cannot start the morning or finish a martini without them.
Perhaps the brand’s clearest analogy is a song. Play an unfamiliar track and someone’s response may be minimal. Play it five times, and they’re humming it in the shower. The value was in the familiarity the brain assembled around the audio file.
In the 1960s, psychologist Robert Zajonc called this the mere-exposure effect. We can come to like what we’ve encountered before, partly because we have encountered it before.
As another example, Apple sold computers and accumulated meaning. Over decades, the company deposited meaning into a piece of fruit with a bite missing, until the mark stopped signifying a computer and started signifying a kind of person. Strip away that accumulated meaning, and you are left with aluminum and glass. A competitor can approximate it in a fiscal quarter, but the meaning cannot be reverse-engineered on a shorter timeline than the one it took to build.
When familiarity breeds contempt
Once a brand is recognized, trusted, and felt, repetition can stop adding value. This is where the old economics curve finally catches up with advertising’s persuasion curve.
The plateau is dangerous because it feels like success. The brand is everywhere—familiar, routine, comfortable—but familiarity and growth aren’t the same. Brands stall, institutions calcify, and relationships stagnate.
Beyond the plateau lies something worse than indifference, which is resentment. Anyone who has endured the same 15-second spot at every streaming break knows the feeling. You resent the advertisement and the brand behind it.
A 2023 Nexxen and MAGNA Media Trials study found that viewers shown the same ad six times in a single hour of streaming reached 92% recall. But viewers also rated it 48% more annoying than average and showed a 16% decline in purchase intent.
That’s known as psychological reactance—when people feel their autonomy being constrained, they push back against the source. Repetition builds familiarity in measured doses, but when excessive, it can foster contempt.
Part of the problem is that our mental dashboards treat every ad impression as identical. Reach and frequency are tallied as interchangeable units, as though the fifth exposure were the same event as the first. It is not—and the fifteenth may be actively working against you.
If an impression’s value depends on where it falls along the curve, then counting impressions without understanding response tracks deposits while ignoring withdrawals. Advertising’s value curve is an arc, flat, then climbing, then—if marketers fail to stop or refresh the message—falling past indifference into contempt.
What marketers should do
A good is worth what it is. A relationship is worth what it has become. For decades, brand builders have applied pizza-slice thinking to something that operates more like a friendship.
In practice, that means three disciplines:
1. Cap frequency before annoyance compounds. The point of diminishing return may arrive sooner than a media plan assumes.
2. Rotate ads so familiarity attaches to the brand rather than to a single spot the audience has memorized against its will.
3. Measure response, not just reach. Recall tells you people have seen you, but it can’t tell you how they feel about seeing you again.
Above all, know when to show up and when to pull back. A fine line exists between the thoughtful text and relentless spam, and a moment when brand equity years in the making begins playing itself out in reverse.
Econ 101 gave marketers a precise theory of how value is spent. It never gave us one for how value is built. We have to draw that curve ourselves.
J. Brooks is founder and CEO at GlassView.