In a hybrid work world where place and time flexibilities are a growing priority among current and potential employees, some employers are weighing in on the topic of PTO benefits and how it will impact their staff members.
While it’s important for companies to create work-life balance options and address the needs of their people, department leaders must also have candid conversations with their teams on performance expectations and the amount of time spent away from the office to prevent any business disruption.
Trying to decide on whether to create individual policies or vacation, sick time, and other forms of leave versus offering an all-inclusive unlimited PTO package? Here are 13 details to keep in mind, courtesy of Fast Company Executive Board members.
1. PERSONALIZED FLEXIBILITY
As a flexible and customizable field service management solution, our core values reflect that as well. Being personalized and flexible with our employees is important and an all-inclusive unlimited PTO package fits that. We work with each individual on the support they personally need to thrive at any given time. For example, we provide family or personal health leaves as needed. – Anand Subbaraj, Zuper
2. HIGHLY COMPETITIVE WORK CULTURES
While unlimited PTO may alleviate concerns about running out of vacation days, so often company culture, specifically in highly competitive cultures, often makes it very difficult to take the extra time. Although there may be some workers who can take as much paid holiday as they want, they will often take less holiday than workers with a fixed number of days, according to the BBC. – Jason Wojahn, Thirdera
3. MINIMUM DAYS REQUIRED
Consider setting a minimum number of required PTO when instituting an unlimited PTO policy. We require that employees take a minimum of 20 days of PTO per year for active recovery, in addition to company holidays. It is critical to be strategic about the policies that protect employees from burnout in order to create a culture of sustainable high performance. – Liza Streiff, Knopman Marks Financial Training
4. PERMISSION BARRIERS
Human motivations vary greatly. In rolling out an all-inclusive and unlimited vacation package, our experience is that some people have struggled to give themselves permission to exercise that privilege. Leadership must consider how to remove the permission barriers and then the operations team must learn the nuance of helping people plan their personal time. – Michelle Hayward, Bluedog
5. MONETARY REIMBURSEMENT
Consider who the policy benefits. Unlimited PTO tends to benefit the company, not the employee. Employees may be uncomfortable or feel guilty taking time off. At Next PR, we have a structured policy. This means that unused days are paid out to employees at the end of the year. They earned the time, so they should be compensated for it if it’s not used. – Shannon Tucker, Next PR
6. HOME LIFE AND WORK STYLE DIFFERENCES
We are making the switch to unlimited PTO in January and our employees couldn’t be happier. Our decision to switch to this model reflects our commitment to flexible working. The pandemic revealed that every employee’s home life and work style is different. Giving them the ability to build their own schedule around their life builds trust and loyalty and boosts productivity. – David Coppins, IntelyCare
7. MAJORITY VERSUS MINORITY WORKFORCE CONCERNS
It is important to apply the 80% to 20% ratio rule when deciding whether to create individual policies for vacation, sick time, and other forms of leave versus offering an all-inclusive unlimited PTO package for employees. Go with the unlimited PTO package if it works for 80% or more of your workforce. It’s important to solve for the majority and then address the minority separately. – Danny Lohrfink, Wealth
8. TIME-OFF GRADE
All-inclusive PTO policies can result in additional requirements or costs for small businesses. Dividing up the categories into vacation days, sick days and other forms of leave can allow your company to offer more time off to your employees while maintaining your cost at a reasonable level. – Kelley Higney, Bug Bite Thing
9. SUSTAINABLE COMPANY CULTURE AND VALUES
Address how you are going to create and sustain the culture and values important to your business in this new hybrid work world, where place and time flexibility mean old norms for building culture are now disrupted. Set aside the idea that culture depends on the office and its associated norms of when employees will be in or out. The office is now just one more tool for culture-building. – Amy Radin, Pragmatic Innovation Partners LLC
10. PREVENTION OF BUSINESS DISRUPTION
An all-inclusive unlimited PTO package is a great way to attract talent and alleviate tracking and efforts on HR and managers. However, managers need to have candid discussions with their employees on performance expectations or planning vacations to prevent business disruption. This is the best option when you have great managers and great employees, but it is not always the case. – Isabelle Guis, Commvault
11. POLICY AND BENEFIT DISPARITIES
Employees talk, even remote employees. Disparities in employee policies and benefits can create unintended rifts between management and employees and can have a negative impact on team morale, even if employees’ concerns about favoritism are more perceived than real. We have found it best to at least compartmentalize benefits by department or leadership level rather than individually. – Tyrone Foster, InvestNet, LLC
12. UNIFIED COMPANY DOWNTIME
In addition to the tremendous flexibility of unlimited PTO, we shut down twice a year for a week. This way, everyone can experience the full benefit of downtime by being offline at the same time. An alternate paid week off is provided to our skeleton team who keeps everything running while most employees enjoy the shutdown. True vacations without the fear of missing out or looming deadlines are game-changing. – Karen Starns, OJO
13. IMPACT OF CLOCK-DRIVEN WORK VERSUS TASK-DRIVEN WORK
What type of job is the employee doing? Is it clock-driven work or task-driven work? Anything that has scheduling requirements should consider the impact of absence, irrespective of the type of absence. This is typically a math problem. The unlimited PTO option works best when there is flexibility in the output that involves the developers, designers, and other staff who fit into this bucket. Flexibility, if offered, must definitely be mutual. – Kris Pazhayanoor, TOTALogistix INC