Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

12 strategies to elevate your Substack presence

To build brand loyalty and engagement on Substack, create unique content that your audience won't find anywhere else.

12-strategies-to-elevate-your-substack-presence

Photo credits: Perfect PNG Studio / Adobe Stock

Profile photo of Fast Company Executive Board

In today’s fickle social media climate, many business leaders and media influencers are turning to Substack as a more stable and direct way to connect with their audience. But standing out in someone’s crowded inbox requires more than just repackaging what you already post elsewhere.

If you want to earn subscribers and keep them coming back, you’ll need to offer something distinct, valuable, and personal—think unfiltered stories, actionable expertise, and exclusive insights. To help you start and grow your Substack base, 12 members of Fast Company Executive Board discuss how to create content that draws readers in and builds long-term engagement.

1. PROVIDE HIGH-VALUE, EXCLUSIVE CONTENT TO ENGAGE YOUR CURRENT AUDIENCE.

Exclusivity is key. You have to assume that this is pulling from your current audience. Substack isn’t likely to expand your reach, but rather increase the frequency of your active audience touchpoints and increase their relatability and ownership with your brand. Rather than thinking about new content, look at what you are currently providing for free and consider gatekeeping 25 percent of the strongest value. – Monica Hickey, The Evoke Agency

2. SHARE ACTIONABLE EXPERTISE FROM YOUR REAL-WORLD EXPERIENCES.

Authenticity and actionable expertise are key. Successful newsletters offer insights drawn directly from real-world experiences—practical advice, strategic perspectives, and transparent storytelling that readers immediately find relevant and valuable. Consistently providing meaningful, value-driven content establishes credibility, deepens trust, and sustains long-term reader interest. – Muhammed Uzum, Grape Law Firm PLLC

3. ALLOW SUBSCRIBERS TO LOOK ‘BEHIND THE CURTAIN.’

Embrace genuine authenticity. Start a “Behind the Curtain” series where you share unfiltered thoughts, failures, and spontaneous ideas. Create polls or challenges that encourage subscribers to contribute topics. Think of your newsletter as a lively conversation rather than a monologue. This honesty and inclusiveness will spark real interest and keep readers eagerly awaiting the next update. – Shawn Galloway, ProAct Safety, Inc.

4. FOCUS ON YOUR AUDIENCE’S NEEDS, NOT YOUR OWN.

Separate yourself from what you think is relevant so as to better learn and understand what’s relevant to your intended audience. Do you like what you write? That’s irrelevant. Focus on what’s useful for your audience, not what you like! Focus on what the intended outcome impact can be rather than how well you make your point. Remember: Your purpose is to get people to think, not to be an amazing thinker. – Jay Steven Levin, WinThinking

5. OFFER SOLUTIONS TO TODAY’S CHALLENGES.

Craft content that anticipates the audience’s challenges and offers strategic solutions. This ensures your Substack remains a timely and indispensable resource aligned with the issues that matter most today. – Dr. Katrina (Katya) Rosseini, KRR Ventures

6. USE FIRST-PARTY RESEARCH IN YOUR WRITING.

Include first-party research. If people know they can consistently count on you for insights they won’t get anywhere else, they’ll subscribe. – Andrea Lechner-Becker, GNW Consulting

7. DELIVER STORIES AND INSIGHTS ABOUT DIGITAL RESILIENCE.

Share behind-the-scenes disaster recovery stories—when businesses lost critical data and how they rebuilt. People love authentic crisis narratives with lessons learned. It positions you as the expert who’s seen it all while delivering genuinely useful insights about digital resilience. – Chongwei Chen, DataNumen Inc.

8. ENSURE YOUR CONTENT FEELS HUMAN, NOT JUST PROMOTIONAL.

A good way to get people to sign up and stick around is to offer something they won’t find on your social media. Some examples are honest behind-the-scenes stories, helpful advice, or maybe even early access to new ideas. You should write like it’s a real person, and not a list, so keep the tone friendly and personal. People connect more when it feels genuine and useful, not just promotional. – Gianluca Ferruggia, DesignRush

9. GO BEYOND WHAT YOU’RE ALREADY OFFERING FOR FREE.

Focus your Substack content on exclusive, actionable insights and authentic storytelling. Subscribers seek unique value beyond what’s freely available online—providing behind-the-scenes perspectives, personal anecdotes, practical takeaways, or expert-level advice differentiates your newsletter. – Britton Bloch, Navy Federal Credit Union

10. TREAT SUBSTACK LIKE A ‘PREMIUM LAYER’ OF CONTENT.

From the people I know with a Substack or similar setup, the best results come from treating it like a premium layer. Keep a steady stream of free content (like a weekly column or newsletter), then offer deeper insights or exclusive perks behind the paywall. It works best when the free stuff is already solid and worth following. – Travis Schreiber, erase.com

11. LET PEOPLE SEE THE ‘MESSY MIDDLE.’

Write from the trenches, not the mountaintop. Share the messy middle—the 2 a.m. pivot, the failure that taught you. People don’t subscribe for polish; they stay for truth. Help them see their struggle in your story. Writing about the gap between what they hired you for versus what they needed, you hit the nerve that makes them lean in and never leave. – Dr. Camille Preston, AIM Leadership, LLC

12. GIVE READERS SPECIFIC, IMMEDIATELY APPLICABLE FRAMEWORKS.

Lead with actionable insights, not just industry commentary. Entrepreneurs and business owners value newsletters that provide immediate implementation. Instead of generic topics, offer content that includes specific frameworks, templates, or step-by-step processes that readers can use right away. Your expertise becomes valuable when it’s immediately applicable. – Joynicole Martinez, The Alchemist Agency