We’re bombarded in the news and on social media with divisive discussions. Holiday meals have turned difficult, with opinions shared that can be upsetting. It’s hard to then go into the workplace and be faced with more of the same. Executives already work hard to create accepting and inclusive cultures. That peace and island of harmony can be overturned in an instant when a colleague shares an unwelcome and possibly offensive statement. While the First Amendment is in force in public, does it need to apply in work situations too?
These nine Fast Company Executive Board members share tips on when and how to quash disruptive discussions and refocus staff members in a productive way.
1. PSYCHOLOGICAL SAFETY FIRST
I think leaders have to become ruthless about protecting psychological safety first. I always anchor my team in our shared mission and values—why we exist, who we serve—and make it clear that personal beliefs are respected, but disrespect is not. I set boundaries around when and how we talk about charged issues (for example, structured spaces or 1:1s, not Slack or email wars). And I model nuance. It’s okay to say “I don’t know yet” or “I’m still processing.” Most importantly, I don’t force everyone into a single “approved” viewpoint. I focus on behaviors, not beliefs, so people can feel safe working together even when they don’t agree on everything.—Kristin Marquet,Marquet Media, LLC
2. A BLAME-FREE OFFICE
Don’t aim for a politics-free office; aim for a blame-free one. Set three norms: no surprise debates in meetings, curiosity before rebuttal, and the right to tap out of any hot topic. Keep bringing people back to shared goals and local problems they can actually fix together.—Shawn M. Galloway, ProAct Safety, Inc.
3. EMPATHY AND CLEAR NORMS
Keep the peace by leading with empathy and anchoring everyone on shared goals. In politically unstable times, people aren’t just reacting to opinions, they’re reacting to stress. Set clear norms, give your team room to breathe, and model calm, respectful dialogue. When leaders show empathy, teams mirror it, and the culture stays focused on trust, performance, and the work that actually matters.—Katrina Rosseini, PhD, KRR Ventures Advisory
4. NO HARMFUL LANGUAGE
In times like these, it’s important to cultivate an environment of respect and open communication. Encourage empathy by creating spaces where your colleagues can express their views without fear of judgment, while maintaining a clear policy against divisive or harmful behavior and language.—Evan Nierman, Red Banyan
5. COMMON GROUND
Continue to highlight your company’s values as the common ground. Focus conversations on shared goals like serving customers and supporting communities, rather than discussing opinions on sensitive matters.—Mark Valentino,Citizens
6. CULTIVATE STEADINESS
The most effective leaders aren’t trying to control the instability outside. They’re cultivating steadiness inside through clarity, consistency, empathy, and values-aligned leadership.—Britton Bloch,Navy Federal Credit Union
7. PROTECT RELATIONSHIPS
Peace at work survives political storms when leaders protect relationships between the employees more fiercely than they protect opinions. We set boundaries, create room for dialogue, and make kindness a performance metric. When respect is the culture, conflict becomes the exception, not the norm.—Volen Vulkov, Enhancv
8. PUBLISH A CONDUCT POLICY
Publish a clear conduct policy that keeps political advocacy out of core work channels and makes discussion spaces opt-in. Provide a short training on respectful debate, name a neutral mediator, and resolve conflicts quickly, before they escalate. Re-anchor conversations to company mission and customer outcomes so work stays productive.—Kevin Leyes, LeyesX and Leyes Media
9. FOCUS ON THE MISSION
The cure to keeping the peace is unifying everyone behind the company’s specific mission and making it clear that while employees have personal passions, work is the place to pursue shared business goals. I really align with the philosophy that we don’t need to agree on politics to do good work together. If we remind the team that our job is to accomplish our specific mission, it becomes much easier to check political debates at the door.—Zander Cook, Lease End