You are testing out a new project. You need someone to write an ESG report and no one internal has that background. You need a sales person to focus solely on one program, to grow it and own it. You need an IT person available 24/7 but it won’t require full-time hours. You need staffing for events. You need a customer service person who will fit into your culture and be responsible for long-term clients.
There is a lot to think about when determining how to structure your workforce. When is it better to bring on an independent contractor and when should you hire an employee? These 14 Fast Company Executive Board members have thought this through for their own companies, and they share how to make that decision.
1. CORE, REPEATABLE WORK
Hire employees for core, repeatable work where you need control, cultural fit, and long-term ownership. Use contractors for specialized, time-boxed projects or skills you don’t plan to scale in-house. When in doubt, run a three-month paid pilot with a contractor and convert only when repeat demand and cultural fit are proven. — Kevin Leyes, LeyesX and Leyes Media
2. USE INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS WHEN DESPERATE
Independent contractors are like mercenaries. They have given up on career advancement in favor of their specific, chosen lifestyle. They come and go without any attachment to a company’s purpose, culture, or team. They operate alone. And demand hazard pay. Accordingly, I would only ever bring one in when we might need that “skill” set. Very infrequently. And only when desperate. — Barney Robinson,Orchard Creative
3. OWNERSHIP AND INSTITUTIONAL KNOWLEDGE
I decide based on how the work needs to live inside the business. If it’s specialized, project-based, or meant to solve a very specific problem, I bring in an independent contractor. They’re faster, sharper, and don’t require long onboarding. If the work is ongoing, foundational, and benefits from real ownership and institutional knowledge, that’s when an employee makes sense. The mistake I see is hiring based on pressure or emotion, instead of being honest about whether the role needs flexibility. — Kristin K. Marquet, Marquet Media, LLC
4. PROJECT DURATION AND EXPERTISE
Consider the duration of the project and the urgency of hiring. If the project is short duration and or requires deep expertise in a short span, contractors can be a better alternative. — Ruchir Nath, Dell Technologies
5. DEFINED OUTCOMES VERSUS ONGOING CAPACITY
Choose an independent contractor when you’re buying a defined outcome from someone who truly operates an independent business. Choose an employee when you need ongoing capacity in a role you will direct and integrate into your core operations. For classification, the label in the contract matters far less than the facts—especially control, financial independence, and the nature of the relationship. — Nagesh Nama, XLM Continuous Intelligence
6. TEST DRIVE
We often use independent contractors as a kind of test drive. Many of our best full-time employees started out as contractors. It’s a low-risk way to see if there’s a strong fit on both sides, and if their skills and work style align with the company’s. If it turns into a long-term relationship and the value is clearly there, we bring them in-house. It’s been one of our most effective hiring strategies. — Zander Cook, Lease End
7. EMPLOYEES MUST BRING GROWTH
We are slower to hire employees versus contractors. I run a startup and each full-time hire must bring growth to our business and to our clients’ business. We work with numerous contractors and we value our relationship with them, as they typically lead or deliver against specific projects. Employees are working across the business and focus on delivering expansion, innovation, and value. Plus they contribute to the company culture. — Mack McKelvey, SalientMG and The Credentialed
8. FILL THE GAPS
We use contractors to fill gaps and cover specialty work that might not justify a full-time role yet. They’re also helpful after creating a minimum viable product, when we need a real rollout but it’s too much work to add to someone’s plate and it’s still not a full job on its own. Employees make sense when the work is ongoing and needs deep ownership. — Travis Schreiber, Erase.com
9. EXPLORATION VERSUS A CLEAR PROBLEM
If the work is outcome-based, time-bound, or still taking shape, I bring in an independent contractor. That kind of work is exploratory. You are buying speed and expertise, rather than long-term ownership. Contractors fit well when the problem is clear and the future still feels open. If the work shapes how the company thinks, decides, or operates daily, that is an employee role. Anything tied to culture, judgment, or long-term direction needs continuity. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, Ohh My Brand and Blushush Technologies
10. TEAM INTEGRATION OR SPECIALIZED NEEDS
I ask myself: “Do I need this person long term and deeply integrated into our team, or is this project-based, short-term, or specialized?” An independent contractor is great for specific skills (AV setup, event tech, design, catering coordination) or projects with a defined start/end. An employee is necessary when the role requires ongoing collaboration, company culture immersion, and consistent accountability. For event production, many of our tactical roles start as contractors but can evolve into full-time positions when the workload grows consistently. — Diana Sabb, Create Something Amazing
11. NATURE OF THE WORK, NOT COST
It comes down to the nature of the work, not the cost of the labor. I ask four questions. First, is the work surge-based or sustained? Second, is the outcome clearly defined? Third, is the work highly regulated or risk-sensitive? Fourth, how much flexibility does the organization need? A flexible workforce is a strategic lever during periods of growth, transformation, or uncertainty. Contractors allow organizations to scale capacity without overcommitting fixed headcount, when used thoughtfully and within guardrails. The best organizations treat contractors and employees as distinct tools in a workforce strategy, not interchangeable labor. — Britton Bloch, Navy Federal Credit Union
12. USE AN AGENCY
If you need speed, specialization, and flexibility, neither may be the best fit. A boutique agency gives you a vetted team, strategic oversight, and scalability without the risk or overhead of hiring. It’s often the fastest path to impact. — Sharon Lee Thony, SLT Consulting
13. MIND THE LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
We choose to use independent contractors only when it is legal to do so. The IRS and other agencies have strict requirements under which work can be done by an independent contractor, and many businesses ignore them (to their potential peril). — Robert W. Sprague, Yes&
14. TIME-BOUND PROBLEM
I ask whether the work is core to our long-term strategy or solving a defined, time-bound problem. Contractors are great for speed and specialization. Employees are essential when institutional knowledge and ownership matter. The mistake is using one to solve the other’s job. — Stephanie Harris, PartnerCentric