Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The new hire isn’t working out

Eleven ways to handle a bad hiring decision.

[Photo: Getty Images]

You ask the tough questions. You check references. The job candidate seems like the perfect fit. You feel lucky to have found such a great new employee. And then soon into the onboarding, you realize you may have made a mistake. Perhaps they embellished their experience or maybe they aren’t such a good cultural fit.

No matter the reason, there are costs to letting them go early and there are costs to keeping them on. Some of those costs might be in personality clashes, or they may be in productivity or work quality. No matter. You must decide how to move forward. These 11 Fast Company Executive Board members share ways to address a potential hiring mistake to make the best of it, for the company and the employee.

1. ADDRESS IT EARLY AND DIRECTLY   

In creative teams, bad hires usually show up in the work before they show up in performance reviews. When the thinking is off, collaboration strains, or standards slip, it’s a signal. Address it directly and early. Either reset expectations and coach with intent, or make a clean call. Letting misalignment linger longer can have a bad effect on the culture and the work. — Goran Paun, ArtVersion

2. KNOW WHEN NOTHING WILL FIX THE PROBLEM

The question that changes things is almost annoyingly simple: If you were hiring for this role today, with everything you now know, would you make the same choice? When you start adding explanations to your answer, that pause says more than any performance review ever will. Some decisions are meant to sit and mature, like a Christmas cake where the fruit soaks in rum for weeks and comes out richer, deeper, better than it was at the start. Other decisions tell you early that the mix is off. Leaving that batter to rest longer does not fix it. It just makes the final bite heavier and harder to get through. Leadership is learning to taste that difference early. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, Ohh My Brand and Blushush Technologies

3. HIRE SLOW, FIRE FAST

My hiring philosophy is simple: Hire slow, and if it is not working, let go fast. If someone is a strong cultural fit but not yet a technical fit, I evaluate whether training, coaching, or a role adjustment can bridge the gap. Either way, I address it quickly and clearly, because keeping the wrong fit too long costs the team more than making a change. — Angie Hughes, Opportunity Knocks

4. YOU CAN’T FIX VALUES AND ATTITUDE

First, I address it quickly, clarify expectations in writing, set a short performance checkpoint, and document outcomes so the situation doesn’t drag on and drain the team. If it’s a skill gap, I coach with specific deliverables. If it’s a values/attitude mismatch, I exit fast because that never trains out. The lesson I apply every time is to tighten the hiring filter upfront, use scorecards, run a paid test project, and conduct reference checks to see how the person performs under pressure. — Kristin Marquet, Marquet Media, LLC

5. REDEPLOY WHEN SKILLS ARE STRONG BUT ROLE FIT IS WEAK

A bad hire is rarely a single point of failure. More often, it’s a systems signal about assessment rigor, role clarity, onboarding, or how work actually gets done versus how it was imagined. Many “bad hires” are misalignments between skills and context: The person can perform, just not in the conditions you’ve created. Once gaps are apparent, distinguish between can’t, won’t, and wasn’t set up to succeed. When skills are strong, but role fit is weak, redeployment preserves institutional knowledge and ROI. Termination has its place, but it should be the final step, not the first reflex. — Britton Bloch, Navy Federal Credit Union

6. OWN IT FAST, THEN ACT EVEN FASTER

Diagnose the miss: Was it skill, culture, expectations, or role fit—and where did the hiring process fail? Give clear, measurable expectations with a short improvement window and weekly check-ins. If they can’t meet the bar quickly, reassign or exit respectfully. Keeping a “wrong seat, wrong bus” hire hurts the whole team. Then capture the lesson and update the hiring system (scorecards, work samples, reference checks) so you don’t repeat it. — Boris Dzhingarov, ESBO Ltd

7. CULTURE AND ACCOUNTABILITY GO TOGETHER

In a small business, every hire carries weight. When someone isn’t the right fit, it’s critical to address it quickly and fairly. Start by evaluating whether the issue stems from skill, culture fit, or expectations—applying those insights to strengthen hiring and onboarding going forward. Treating the situation as a learning opportunity not only protects the team momentum, but it also reinforces a culture where accountability and growth go hand in hand. — Mark Valentino, Citizens

8. CLARITY, NOT FALSE HOPE

The moment you realize a hire isn’t right, your job is clarity, not false hope. I like to address it quickly, honestly, and with empathy. Delaying the conversation doesn’t protect anyone; it quietly damages the team and the trust you’ve built with them. Owning the mistake early preserves trust and gives everyone dignity, including the person who deserves clarity. — Volen Vulkov, Enhancv

9. ACKNOWLEDGE THE MISTAKE QUICKLY

The first step is to acknowledge the mistake quickly. Assess the impact, then take action to either coach the employee toward success or make a swift exit. What matters most is minimizing disruption and learning from the decision. Use the experience to refine your hiring process, clarify expectations earlier, and build stronger, more targeted assessments for future hires. Bad hires are part of the journey, but they can drive better decisions moving forward. — Solomon Thimothy, OneIMS

10. CLEAR FEEDBACK AND IMPROVEMENT PLAN

I address it quickly and directly, starting with clear feedback and a short, structured improvement plan. If the gap is skill-based, I invest in targeted coaching. If it is values or ownership-related, I move on fast, because delaying only compounds the cost for the team and the business. — Shashank Chaurasia, MooresLab AI

11. REMEDIATION PLAN WITH FIXED REVIEW DATE

Own it quickly, document performance gaps, and set a short, transparent remediation plan with clear milestones and a fixed review date. If improvement stalls, cut the loss fast, reassign remaining work to high-performers or contractors, and run a short post-mortem to fix the hiring rubric and interview checklist so the mistake does not repeat. — Kevin Leyes, LeyesX and Leyes Media