The adage that it’s cheaper to retain a customer than to acquire a new one is timeless. Studies show that it is five to 25 times more costly to gain new customers compared to keeping your current customers. One way to do that is through high-quality subscription and service models. Perhaps you offer retainers. Or you sell an “as-a-service” product. Maybe you run a membership community, providing advice and expertise.
What these all have in common is giving your customers value for their money. It’s easy for clients to get distracted by a shiny new service or product someone else raves about. Your goal is keeping them happy and stable with you. That requires overcoming inertia and ensuring that you are staying a step or two ahead of your customers’ needs, even if they don’t yet know what those are.
These 12 Fast Company Executive Board members have already gone through this thought exercise, and have executed on it. Use their tips to improve your own subscription and service models.
1. GAIN MOMENTUM
I stopped thinking of subscriptions as access and started thinking of them as momentum. Most subscription products focus on giving people more. More features. More content. More updates. That sounds generous, but it usually overwhelms users. What actually adds value is helping them move forward without friction. The strongest subscriptions do not beg to be renewed. They become part of how someone works or thinks. Canceling them feels like losing momentum, not losing access. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, Ohh My Brand and Blushush Technologies
2. ADD ACCOUNTABILITY
Instead of adding more content, add accountability. Community challenges, check-ins, or progress nudges create commitment loops. People don’t stay subscribed because there’s more to consume, they stay because something expects them to show up. — Volen Vulkov, Enhancv
3. PARTNERSHIP, NOT ONE-OFF PROJECTS
Agencies used to run on retainers that covered time and availability. Today, clients are looking for something simpler and more practical: ongoing access to a team that knows their business. They’re not buying hours, they’re buying continuity, shared context, and guidance across design and technology. When that relationship is steady, work moves faster, decisions improve, and progress compounds. Call it a retainer or a subscription, the value is in the partnership, not one-off projects. — Goran Paun, ArtVersion
4. OUTCOME GUARANTEES
We add outcome guarantees: a concierge onboarding sprint that delivers baseline KPIs, quarterly simulated incidents to validate playbooks, and a CFO-facing report that translates protection into avoided loss. Those features convert subscribers into customers who pay more for measurable, repeatable results. — Kevin Leyes, LeyesX and Leyes Media
5. DEMONSTRATE PROGRESS
The most overlooked opportunity in subscription models isn’t pricing or packaging; it’s progress. Subscriptions fail when they deliver access but don’t demonstrably move the customer forward. Personalize the journey, not just the feed. Most subscriptions personalize recommendations; few personalize outcomes. Make progress visible and portable. The novel move isn’t adding more features. It’s designing the subscription to prove progress, adapt intelligently, and compound value over time. When a service becomes an engine for advancement, not consumption, it earns longevity. — Britton Bloch, Navy Federal Credit Union
6. DATA AND EXPERTISE
Subscription models deliver the most value when data is paired with expertise. Programs that combine operational insights with proactive maintenance planning, performance reviews, and ongoing professional support help customers move from reacting to issues, to preventing them. When subscriptions actively guide better decisions and execution, you become a long-term operational partner helping drive TOC targets rather than a standalone service provider. — Michael Field, Toyota Material Handling North America
7. PERSONALIZATION AT SCALE
To add value to a subscription model, offer personalization at scale. Use customer data to create tailored experiences or content that evolves with each subscriber’s journey. Another idea is to implement success milestones, rewarding customers for reaching certain usage or engagement levels. This turns subscriptions into a relationship, not just a transaction, increasing loyalty and lifetime value. — Solomon Thimothy, OneIMS
8. CONTENT THAT DEEPENS CONNECTION
At our boutique agency, we help direct-to-consumer subscription brands to build value through content that deepens connection: thoughtful onboarding flows, surprise bonuses, and seasonal storytelling. The goal is simple: Make every subscriber feel seen and give them a reason to stay. — Sharon Lee Thony, SLT Consulting
9. CUSTOMER SERVICE AND SUPPORT
Make customer service and support a core feature, not an afterthought. Too many subscriptions lose trust because help is slow, confusing, or unavailable. When customers feel cared for and quickly supported, they stay longer and tell others. — Angie Hughes, Opportunity Knocks
10. PROVIDE NOVELTY
Subscriptions live or die on whether people feel they’re getting something they can’t find elsewhere. Novelty is the name of the game, introducing an element tailored to the end-user’s experience. Tech allows us to go global and scale, but often we miss culture and nuance details that creates real stickiness, such as details that only the “locals” would know. Similar to personalization, glocalization provides elements of culture that offer the kind of context that enables a product or service to surprise and delight as well as create a genuine connection with the end reader or user. — Lexi Sydow, The ATTN Economy
11. VALUE-STACKING
I like “value stacking” that makes the subscription feel smarter over time. That includes personalized ROI dashboards, outcome-based tiers, a concierge layer, member-only assets, compounding benefits, and community with purpose. — Boris Dzhingarov, ESBO Ltd.
12. LAYERED VALUE
I focus on layered value rather than more content, including strategic checkpoints, implementation prompts, and real-time relevance tied to what members are facing now. Adding periodic private AMAs or timely playbooks keeps the subscription feeling alive and indispensable. The goal is to make members feel supported in motion, not overwhelmed with static resources. — Kristin Marquet, Marquet Media, LLC