Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How to fix a negative business reputation online

Even the most successful companies can make missteps, and when those mistakes involve leadership, the consequences can be severe.

Members pictured from left to right [Image credit: Photos courtesy of the individual members].

Profile photo of Fast Company Executive Board

A company’s reputation is a crucial asset that can take years to build but can be destroyed in an instant. Negative publicity and online backlash can quickly spread after leadership mistakes, causing irreparable damage to a company’s reputation. However, there are steps that a company can take to clean up its negative business reputation online and regain the trust of its clients.

To help, a panel of Fast Company Executive Board members recommended some effective strategies that can help turn things around and get your business back in the good graces of potential and current clients, even after past leadership missteps.

1. BE TRANSPARENT.

Hit it straight up in the press. Have an interview with the founder, owner, and CEO and address the issue. Maybe it all stems from a philosophy—perhaps they are at odds with the legislation or the policies. You need to share your story. Then, ask your long-time customers to share their testimonials and user-generated content videos and make sure they are on your website and reviews. – Rich DePencier, Chief Outsiders

2. APOLOGIZE SINCERELY AND OFFER THE NEXT STEPS.

It’s absolutely possible to be forgiven—people love a redemption story. They simply want you to sincerely apologize for past mistakes, thank them for their constructive feedback, and lay out a new direction based on your learnings. That not only helps clean up past mistakes, but it also makes your customers feel like they are part of your journey. – Scott Baradell, Idea Grove

3. GRAB CONTROL OF REVIEW SITES.

I was surprised to learn that no one from our company had claimed our GlassDoor or Indeed pages. There was a ton of negative stuff that wasn’t even about us. There were mistakes meant for another company with a similar name. Most of the review sites also have paid programs that can help with reputation management cleanup, SEO, and soliciting reviews from positive talent. – Rob Davis, Novus Media

4. DEMONSTRATE YOUR COMPANY’S CHANGES.

The most important thing a company can do to clean up its reputation is to show that it has made real changes. This could mean changing leadership, offering training, improving communication, or changing policies and procedures. Then, be vocal about implementing these changes. When you display real attempts to improve, people will believe that you’re trustworthy and you will earn back goodwill. – Syed Balkhi, WPBeginner

5. OWN UP TO YOUR MISTAKES.

The most important thing to do is to acknowledge the negative reviews and accept responsibility. If it’s possible to publish a root-cause-analysis (RCA) then do that. People are willing to forgive mistakes if one is willing to accept them. The next step is to talk about what’s being done to address the issues. Keep hammering the message across forums. Over time, sentiment will change. – Sachin Gupta, HackerEarth

6. HOLD YOUR COMPANY RESPONSIBLE.

To clean up a negative business reputation, you have to “own” the problem(s) that led to the negativity; engage your stakeholders to develop a strategy to solve the problem that led to the reputational gap; share openly how you’re moving your company from point A (the problem) to point B (the better future); and stick to substance over spin, because your audience is wise and knows the difference. – Anna Dewar Gully, Tidal Equality

7. GENUINELY SHOW HOW YOU’VE CHANGED.

Addressing the issues that led to the negative reputation completely, humbly, and by stressing with full transparency what you’ve done to assure that these issues will never arise again is a winning formula. At the end of the day, if you can get your dissenters to see the human side of things and create relatability, most people are willing to understand and forgive. – Richard RB Botto, Stage 32

8. DETERMINE THE ROOT ISSUE.

Too often, leaders react quickly, trying to mitigate leadership missteps. Failing to understand and address the root issue can create secondary and tertiary breaches in trust. Actions speak louder than words. Be sure to take responsibility, drive change and remain humble about what you might not fully understand. – Camille Preston, AIM Leadership, LLC

9. BE HUMBLE, AUTHENTIC, AND ACCEPT RESPONSIBILITY.

A negative business reputation can come from a lot of things, but most likely a bad review from somewhere. If it is on social media, respond to it. Don’t be accusatory, be humble. Apologize, ask how their experience could be better, and talk about how you can rectify it. People can understand and forgive a mistake, particularly if you strive to fix it. – Jason Hall, Five Channels

10. HAVE AN INCIDENT RESPONSE PLAN TO RESPOND QUICKLY.

Contrary to popular belief, mistakes can be forgiven. Although, it is challenging to do so without the right strategy in place. If a company finds itself receiving backlash online, brands and stakeholders need to respond quickly and effectively. Relying on an incident response plan, strong internal communications, and media relations, a company can salvage its identity before it is beyond repair. – Kathleen Lucente, Red Fan Communications

11. CREATE A REVIEW ACQUISITION STRATEGY.

For businesses looking to engage clients online, reviews and testimonials can help to rebuild a company’s online reputation and boost SEO. Employ a review acquisition strategy from happy clients (just ask!) and ensure that your company’s Google Business Profile, LinkedIn Page, and any relevant directory listings, like Clutch or Yelp, showcase how your business is at a five-star level now. – Sharon Lee Thony, SLT Consulting

12. ADDRESS ONLINE REVIEWS.

Start with cleaning up and addressing reviews on your Glassdoor. This is often the first place prospective employees or partners look, and you want to make sure you’re addressing any concerns raised by negative reviews or feedback. While it’s a great first step, acknowledge that repairing your reputation takes time and patience. – Shannon Tucker, Next PR

13. MAKE A STRONG EFFORT TO CHANGE, BUT HAVE PATIENCE.

Reputation is breakable and fixable. Understand the magnitude of past missteps. Then address the elephant in the room! Acknowledge what the company has perceived to do wrong. Apologize for it and make it right. Be transparent when dealing with clients. Transparency builds trust. Remember, repairing a damaged reputation takes time, so have patience and trust the process. – Candice Georgiadis, Digital Agency, Inc

14. CREATE A TRANSPARENT AND CONSISTENT PLAN OF ACTION.

It is definitely possible to clean up a negative business reputation, but it takes intentional effort. One of the first things a business can do is create a plan of action. This plan should embrace transparency and consistency in communication and action, proving to consumers that the company is committed to making long-term changes. – Reuben Yonatan, GetVoIP

15. REFLECT ON PAST MISTAKES AND SHARE YOUR PROGRESS.

Will it be a quick fix? No. Is it possible? You bet. People value self-awareness and respect companies that can acknowledge their mistakes and take the appropriate steps to ensure they don’t happen again. Share what you’ve learned from these situations and be specific about what you’ll be doing differently going forward. Bonus points for reporting against your progress in the quarters that follow. – Tom Floyd, Flouracity