Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

14 ways to create a podcast listeners can’t stop recommending

In today's digital landscape, a great podcast builds a following, sparks conversation, and earns repeat listeners.

14-ways-to-create-a-podcast-listeners-cant-stop-recommending

Photo credits: Jacob Lund / Adobe stock

Profile photo of Fast Company Executive Board

Launching a podcast is easy—building one people actually want to listen to is another story. With thousands of shows fighting for attention, success comes down to what you say, how you say it, and who you’re saying it to.

Strong production helps, but standout content starts with clarity, originality, and a clear connection to your audience. To help you create a series that lasts, 14 Fast Company Executive Board members share their best strategies for producing podcast content that engages, delivers value, and builds loyal listeners.

1. BE YOUR AUTHENTIC SELF.

Authenticity, authenticity, authenticity! Podcasts are an audio medium, but you are talking directly to your audience. Making personal connections to your target listener is key to developing, growing, and expanding a dedicated listenership. Sounding great and clear with a good microphone and editing makes the experience that much more enjoyable and likely to have your audience return and recommend! – Eric Cohen, NuVoodoo

2. MAKE QUALITY YOUR TOP PRIORITY.

The explosion of new media formats such as podcasting, social media, and more means that choices are abundant, but quality is never a commodity. Much of this content is not original, not well-sourced, and often misleading. There is emerging evidence that people are hungry for well-sourced content from experts who have relevant expertise and are not just repeating the prevailing media narrative. – Ronald M. Razmi, Zoi Capital

3. DELIVER CONTENT WORTH COMING BACK FOR.

Focus on just that: standout content. That means unique insights, compelling guests, and storytelling that offers real, practical value. Listeners are quick to tune out filler, so don’t publish just to stay busy. Make sure each episode delivers something fresh, thoughtful, and worth coming back for. – Evan Nierman, Red Banyan

4. SHOW A GENUINE INTEREST IN THE TOPICS YOU COVER.

Start your podcast with a genuine desire to learn about something you really care about. For example, I’m obsessed with building brand and business momentum; thus, I created a podcast to talk with makers of momentum. Oh, it also helps to give your series a great title. – Matt Hofherr, Barrett Hofherr

5. BRING SOMETHING DIFFERENT TO THE SHOW.

If the content itself isn’t totally unique, then your take on it needs to be. That could be your depth of knowledge, the chemistry with your co-host, your format, or your tone. – Travis Schreiber, erase.com

6. ALWAYS CONSIDER YOUR AUDIENCE.

You need to be laser-focused on the audience. There are simply too many podcasts to win otherwise. Once you have that, focus on the format. Don’t just show up and talk; you are not Joe Rogan. Create segments. Lastly, prepare your guests. Your guest is also not Joe Rogan. Most podcasters have boring guests who talk in a boring way. Prepare your guests with sound bites and then execute. – Andrea Lechner-Becker, GNW Consulting

7. PRIORITIZE STORYTELLING OVER EXPERTISE.

When producing a podcast series, it is better to focus on storytelling rather than interviews. Instead of having experts show their knowledge, incorporate real-world, behind-the-scenes, or surprising experiences into your podcast. – Gianluca Ferruggia, DesignRush

8. SERVE A SPECIFIC NICHE WITH VALUE.

Focus on a niche topic with a clear value proposition. Interview guests who bring unique insights, and structure episodes with engaging hooks and actionable takeaways. Consistency in format, quality, and publishing builds trust. Standout podcasts solve problems and create loyal communities. – Stephen Nalley, Black Briar Advisors

9. SOLVE REAL PROBLEMS FOR LISTENERS.

The most successful podcasts become indispensable by consistently delivering actionable insights that listeners can’t easily find elsewhere. Instead of asking, “What do I want to talk about?” ask, “What challenge does my ideal listener face every day, and how can I help them overcome it in each episode?” This approach transforms your podcast from entertainment into a valuable, sought-after resource. – Kathleen Lucente, Red Fan Communications

10. LET YOUR AUDIENCE SHAPE YOUR CONTENT.

After 13 years, more than 1,000 episodes, and over 100 million listens and views, we’ve tried it all. Authenticity, a unique lens, quality audio, and conversational skills matter. But a frequent failure is thinking you know what your audience wants, only to be wrong. Take the time to survey them. Ask what specific topics they want to know about. Then, build your editorial calendar around those insights. – Jonathan Fields, Spark Endeavors | Good Life Project®

11. ASK IF YOUR PODCAST ADDS TRUE VALUE.

It is very noisy in the podcast world, so before you launch your own, think about the value you’ll be adding. Will it be just another podcast, or will it be somewhat unique and add value to its listeners? Then you’ll need quality guests, tools, content, and a marketing plan for it. But start with the podcast first. Just because you think it’s a good idea, it doesn’t mean it is. – Al Sefati, Clarity Digital, LLC

12. BUILD COMMUNITY, NOT JUST CONTENT.

To create a standout podcast in 2025, start with a community-first approach; live where your audience lives. Let communities build community by co-creating content, amplifying real voices, and fostering shared purpose. When listeners feel like collaborators, not just consumers, your podcast becomes a movement, not just media. – Val Vacante, dentsu

13. USE VULNERABILITY TO STAND OUT.

Let vulnerability be your differentiator. Ask the questions you’re afraid to ask. Podcasts fail because they play it safe, recycling surface wisdom. Go where it’s uncomfortable. When you voice the doubt everyone feels but won’t say, you create sacred space. Others will reveal what they’ve never shared because you went first. Real conversations are shared the most. – Dr. Camille Preston, AIM Leadership, LLC

14. CRAFT STRONG THEMES.

Build each episode around a compelling, audience-relevant theme, then layer in authentic storytelling and expert insights. Consistency in tone and value keeps listeners engaged, while strong narratives and clear takeaways set your show apart in a crowded market. – Maria Alonso, Fortune 206