Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

15 factors for brands to consider when developing a rewards program

Looking to boost business with a client rewards program? Keep these factors in mind to ensure it's a success.

15-factors-for-brands-to-consider-when-developing-a-rewards-program

Photo credits: Adobe Stock / Alexandra

Profile photo of Fast Company Executive Board

Incentive and rewards programs can encourage repeat business from loyal customers. However, simply offering points or perks won’t necessarily drive long-term loyalty.

To have a real, lasting impact, your program needs to be thoughtfully designed around what truly motivates customers and delivers mutual value. With this in mind, the members of Fast Company Executive Board share key factors to consider when developing a client rewards program and why it’s so critical to get these details right.

1. CLARITY OF PURPOSE

The one factor to get right when creating a rewards program in a tight market is clarity of purpose. In B2C, the goal should be long-term affinity, not just short-term sales. The best programs deepen emotional loyalty by making consumers feel seen, valued, and rewarded. It all starts by answering one essential question: What is in it for me? – Melissa Katrincic, Durham Distillery

2. GENUINE CLIENT VALUE

The key is to discover a path that amplifies the thing your client is in pursuit of in their current reality. You need their business to thrive. But your services, what they pay for, may not be the only, or even the most, valuable thing you can offer in the current moment. Access. Connection. Insight. Relationship. Networking. Commitment. Customize and keep it simple. But make it real. – Maury Giles, Material

3. REWARDS THAT ALIGN WITH CLIENT IDENTITY

I think we should design client rewards that help sync with client identity, not just behavior. It can be hard to align incentives with what clients aspire to and also have it be innovative or get some recognition or influence, which drives more emotional engagement. When clients feel like part of the project and shaping the brand’s future, loyalty becomes a shared mission, not just a transaction. – Dan Sorensen

4. VIABILITY HURDLES TO BE OVERCOME

Use client reward and incentive programs to overcome viability hurdles as clients introduce new products and services. For example, if a client’s innovations require customers to change processes or practices, incentive programs can help soften the cost of change. While many of us focus on desirability and feasibility when bringing innovation to market, viability is often the key challenge. – Steven Kowalski, Creative License (TM) Consulting Services

5. BENEFITS THAT ENHANCE THE CLIENT EXPERIENCE

A strong client incentive program should offer tangible value that drives long-term loyalty. Instead of generic discounts, businesses can provide exclusive strategy sessions, early access to premium services, or VIP perks that enhance the client experience while reinforcing brand credibility and trust. – Kristin Marquet, Marquet Media, LLC

6. TAILORED REWARDS BASED ON CUSTOMER BEHAVIOR

When developing a client incentive program, focus on personalization. Tailoring rewards to customer preferences increases engagement and loyalty. Use data analytics to track behaviors and offer relevant discounts, exclusive perks, or referral bonuses. A well-designed program strengthens relationships, encourages repeat business, and sets you apart in a competitive market. – Stephen Nalley, Black Briar Advisors

7. SIMPLICITY AND TRANSPARENCY

When designing a client incentive program, simplicity and clarity are crucial. Ensure rewards are easy to understand, attainable, and valuable to your audience. Transparency in how clients earn and redeem benefits builds trust. Additionally, tiered incentives can encourage deeper engagement, offering greater perks for long-term loyalty. A well-executed program drives retention and brand advocacy. – Maria Alonso, Fortune 206

8. MEASURABLE IMPACT ON RETENTION OR REVENUE

In a tight market, client incentives should drive measurable impact, not just loyalty. Instead of generic rewards, structure incentives around actions that directly improve retention or revenue, such as rewarding repeat shipments in freight or early commitment discounts. This ensures incentives create value for both clients and the business, making them sustainable rather than just a cost. – Albert Lie, Forward Labs

9. VIP EXPERIENCES THAT DRIVE REPEAT BUSINESS

Instead of offering straight discounts, you could provide VIP experiences, extended warranties, or bundled services that enhance the perceived value without a high direct cost. The program would drive loyalty and repeat business while maintaining profitability. – Britton Bloch, Navy Federal Credit Union

10. PERCEPTION OF VALUE AND RELEVANCE

To boost business in a tight market, business leaders should ensure that client rewards programs are perceived as valuable and relevant to the clients that they serve. Without a valuable offering, the program could seem like extra work to both the client and your internal teams, and be a missed opportunity and not a value-add. – Justin Rende, Rhymetec

11. EASE OF ‘WINNING’

Make it easy for people to win. We’ve offered client referral incentives for more than eight years, and we keep the path simple. Some clients even turned it into a side hustle, sending leads our way and earning a cut. In tight markets, giving people a reason to promote you, especially if they can white label the service, is a win-win. – Travis Schreiber, erase.com

12. MUTUALLY BENEFICIAL BEHAVIORS

Rewards should drive behaviors that benefit both sides, like adoption of new features, data sharing, or multi-year commitments. In a tight market, programs that reinforce partnership, demonstrate shared success, and create long-term value will stand out and drive loyalty. – Gabriel Lopez-Bernal, Icomera

13. REDUCTION OF FRICTION

Focus on friction reduction rather than on discounting. In testing, we proved that usage-based rewards that automatically trigger, like a free parallel test after a certain number of test runs are completed, create much more consumer loyalty than a point-based system that is used to redeem something. – Asad Khan, LambdaTest Inc.

14. ALIGNMENT WITH CLIENT NEEDS AND PREFERENCES

Consider the alignment of the rewards with the client’s needs and preferences. Some customers value high-touch service and proactive engagement to help them make informed financial decisions; a universal service model may not fully meet the unique needs of all customers. Stay committed to listening to both colleagues and clients, incorporating their valuable feedback. – Mark Valentino, Citizens

15. PERKS THAT MATTER TO EACH CUSTOMER

Make it worth their while. In a tight market, generic discounts won’t cut it—customers want rewards that feel personal, not predictable. Use data-driven insights to offer perks they actually care about, whether it’s exclusive access, bonus perks, or VIP treatment. The goal isn’t just a one-time sale—it’s turning buyers into brand loyalists who stick around long after the promo ends – Stephanie Harris, PartnerCentric